Smart motorways: fines or re-training for those who break the rules

Smart motorways

The government is investigating fining more drivers who ignore lane closures on smart motorways. Highways England, which manages the motorway network, is currently trialling cameras designed to automatically snap cars driving in lanes marked with a red cross.

Drivers caught illegally using the closed lanes could then be hit with a £100 fine. And police chiefs are now looking at retraining for offenders – the equivalent of a speed awareness course – to ensure drivers don’t break the law again. These changes could be brought in as quickly as March 2018. Read on to find out more.

How do smart motorways work?

They are sections of existing motorways where the hard shoulder can be opened and used as a regular carriageway. They feature message boards on overhead gantries which display variable speed limits depending on traffic conditions. When a lane is closed, reverting to a traditional hard shoulder, the signs above show a red cross. This is designed as a safety measure in case broken down or rescue vehicles are on the hard shoulder.

Smart motorways

What is the problem?

Increasing numbers of drivers are ignoring warning signals that lanes are closed. CCTV cameras monitor all smart motorway sections. And there are speed cameras to ensure drivers comply with variable limits. Nonetheless, figures obtained by Radio 5 Live reveal that between 2014-15 and 2015-16 there was an 18 per cent increase in drivers fined for illegal hard shoulder use.

From December 2016 to December 2017, Highways England sent out around 80,000 letters to drivers who had been spotted flouting smart motorway rules. Around a third of those letters were to car owners spied driving in closed carriageways.

Why the fines?

The authorities are keen that ignoring instructions on smart motorways doesn’t become the norm. A spokesman said: “We close lanes for a reason and drivers ignoring red Xs puts them and others at risk. Since we started issuing warning letters we have seen a decrease in the number of drivers ignoring lane closures.” The cameras that are currently being trialled will be linked to the gantry signs and automatically snap drivers in lanes that are closed to cars. Drivers will then receive a fixed penalty notice with a fine of £100 and three penalty points – the same as going through a red light.

Find out how to drive on a smart motorway here

Police worry drivers don’t understand smart motorways

There is concern among police chiefs that drivers don’t understand when they can and can’t use the hard shoulder on smart motorways. Suzette Davenport from the National Police Chiefs’ Council said: “There are people who will now use the hard shoulder if there is a queue of traffic so they get off (the motorway) more quickly because they don’t want to sit in that queue.”

Davenport explained there is currently no driver re-training course for motorway offenders. However, she revealed the police are in discussion with Highways England about developing motorway driver re-training. Those caught driving in a closed lane would be offered this as an alternative to a fine and points.

Tips for driving on smart motorways

Highways England offers the following tips for drivers on smart motorways:

  • Never drive in a lane closed by a red ‘X’
  • Keep to the speed limit shown on the gantries
  • A solid white line indicates the hard shoulder – don’t drive in it unless directed
  • A broken white line indicates a normal running lane
  • If your vehicle experiences difficulties, eg warning light, exit the smart motorway immediately if possible
  • Use the refuge areas for emergencies if there’s no hard shoulder
  • Put your hazard lights on if you break down

Read more about stopping on motorways here.

4 comments on “Smart motorways: fines or re-training for those who break the rules

  1. Eric Hayman 19/01/2018 11:40 AM

    There is nothing “smart” about doing away with the hard shoulder and replacing it with occasional very limited length “refuge areas”. Some vehicles have a “get you home” mode which cuts the maximum speed down drastically if the electronic management system thinks there is a fault. With no hard shoulder for scores of miles in some cases, drivers are faced with continuing in Lane One until a refuge area, service area or junction is reached.

    I have already experienced the effect of no hard shoulder on the M3 – when a vehicle had broken down and was not able to reach the next refuge area, service area or junction. Other traffic had to pull out into Lane Two, creating a hazard for anyone caught up in the breakdown.

    “Smart” motorways are simply dumb, dangerous and a cheap way of making more lanes. The hard shoulder is the equivalent of an insurance policy; maybe the so smart government will say there is no need for vehicle insurance. After all, consider how often a vehicle owner makes a claim with how often that same motorist needs to use the hard shoulder. Go compare.

    And how quickly will lane closures be lifted once the lane is clear? From past experience, time and again lane closure signs have remained despite the obstruction having been removed. Drivers need to trust what they see as being correct.

    • Mick Hall 08/06/2019 5:03 PM

      Cars can and do stop dead and that is what may well happen to many drivers and passengers who will be wiped off the road if they are in a section without a hard shoulder.These idiots who thought of the no hard shoulder drive new or nearly new cars and do not have a clue as any mechanic has regarding older cars.
      Those who thought of that stupid idea have not got a clue about road safety. Furthermore they should be made to stand up to face the public of safe drivers….
      They need dealing with but who are they….
      No Hard Shoulder should rightly be revoked immediately and I mean right NOW.

  2. Mick Hall 08/06/2019 4:55 PM

    Whoever thought that no hard shoulder is OK should be sent straight to prison for the intent of killing people……….. With 57 years no claims and driving on the M1 two weeks ago with no hard shoulder that I will never go on again I would confirm that the so called improvement are highly dangerous……. If a car stops abruptly with no hard should the last thing a driver needs is to look at lights to tell him that lane is closed. The designers idea of that one must be a pedal cyclist with not a clue regarding road safety..

  3. John carr 09/07/2019 11:47 PM

    I agree totally with what you say, what concerns me most is why vehicles on the hard shoulder, as it was, become magnets to other vehicles, has technology thrown our driving skills into reverse.
    I would like some immediate legislation to be brought in to enable a single bright coloured
    LED, to be mounted on the roof of every vehicle to flash a warning to other drivers of their existence , much like emergency vehicles, but only for use on motorways.
    I do not feel that hazard warning lights are an effective indicator as they are too low, and too dim to give adequate warning.

    Lane signage on smart m/ways, sometimes is only indicated on the left of the carriageway, each lane must have its own indication.

Leave a Reply